Dupes Similar to In The Stars by Bath & Body Works

All products recommended on Fragrance Review are independently researched, tested, reviewed, and selected by our editorial team. When you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

Share now or save for later!

In The Stars is a warm amber and wood fragrance that Bath and Body Works released in 2018. It is a versatile fragrance option for any weather and time of day, featuring a radiantly warm blend of uplifting citrus, earthy sandalwood, and spicy amber and musk. Unfortunately, while this scent is still available at Bath and Body Works as a lotion, shower gel, and body mist, the perfume has become more difficult to find online. I found 11 fragrances that evoke the same creamy, sweet oud vibe as seen in In The Stars. Let’s explore them together.

In the Stars: Here’s What We Are Looking For

In The Stars smells like an intoxicating blend of sweet tangerine, sultry amber, and fragrant woody notes. This fragrance smells much more expensive than it is and has received frequent comparisons to Baccarat Rouge 540. It is soft and understated while remaining detectable throughout the day.

When finding your signature dupe of In The Stars, there are a few specific features to consider. First, ensure the opening is bright and fresh with citrus and fruit notes. Strawberry and pear create a similar vibe, but you’ll want to avoid any accord that becomes too candied as it develops. Next, we want options with intense amber or sandalwood notes that become more prominent throughout the day. Finally, it is important for the base to be musky and woody, and amber notes should remain throughout wear. These characteristics will guide us to the perfect dupe for In The Stars.

Here are my top recommendations for fragrances that I think you should try if you are a fan of In The Stars.

11 Dupes of In The Stars

1. Brazilian Crush Cheirosa ’68 by Sol de Janeiro

Brazilian Crush Cheirosa by Sol de Janeiro
Brazilian Crush Cheirosa by Sol de Janeiro

If you’re looking for a fragrance with an airy vibe, check out Brazilian Crush Cheirosa ’68. The opening is sweeter than In The Stars, and it’s likely due to the juicy litchi fruit top notes. The opening is a bit tropical too. The middle notes eventually shift to jasmine and aquatic. I detected subtle hints of cotton candy and strawberries although they are not listed in the official notes list. The base is similarly musky, though it remains sweeter for the duration of the perfume. Overall, I found this a very soft fragrance and a suitable alternative for In The Stars.

2. Dream Moon by Pacifica

Dream Moon by Pacifica
Dream Moon by Pacifica

For a slightly woodier vibe with a similar opening, try Dream Moon by Pacifica. The first spray has a familiar sweetness to In The Stars, but sandalwood notes and patchouli take hold as it dries down. There is a hint of fragrant rose that is a bit different, but there is also a sweet fruity vibe that becomes more prominent as it settles. The combination of a woody dry down and sweet notes is very reminiscent of In The Stars, and the price point is also reasonable.

3. Crystal by ALT.

Crystal by ALT
Crystal by ALT

While Crystal is a dupe for Baccarat Rouge 540, I decided to include it on this list because it’s often compared to In The Stars. The opening was a bit sweeter and reminded me of burnt sugar. However, the middle is woody, reminding me of how In The Stars develops. It becomes spicy as it dries down, though the woody and sweet vibes remain throughout the day. So, while Crystal is not an exact dupe for In The Stars, this fragrance has a comparable vibe. I also think the spiciness makes it more appropriate as an evening option.

4. Dark Cherry & Amber by Banana Republic

Dark Cherry Amber by Banana Republic
Dark Cherry Amber by Banana Republic

If you enjoy the sweet and woody dry down of In The Stars but also like cherry notes, Dark Cherry & Amber by Banana Republic is worth a try. There is a bold sour cherry note that appears right at first spray. However, it fades quickly and takes more of a sweet floral turn due to the freesia. After a while, the scent becomes more gourmand, which is somewhat different than In The Stars. However, as it settles, praline and amber notes take center stage. Cedar notes prevent this perfume from becoming too sweet, which reminds me of the balance of notes within In The Stars. While the projection is relatively weak, it transforms into a pleasant skin scent within an hour.

5. Midnight Bloom by Victoria’s Secret

Midnight Bloom by Victorias Secret
Midnight Bloom by Victorias Secret

For something that’s a little less musky with sweeter notes, try Midnight Bloom. I immediately noticed a masculine opening with my first spray. After a few minutes, this fragrance turns floral, and a hint of resin and woody notes strengthen as it dries down. Midnight Bloom seems to settle very similarly to In The Stars, though it’s a bit sweeter overall. I think the longevity is comparable, and the projection is a bit bolder.

6. Cloud by Ariana Grande

Cloud by Ariana Grande
Cloud by Ariana Grande

If you want a longer-lasting fragrance and don’t mind spending a bit more, you’ll enjoy Cloud by Ariana Grande. The opening is quite lactonic, and I noticed a strong pear note. This fragrance lingers and takes time to develop, which is excellent if you enjoy a complex fragrance experience. Cloud is creamy, and there is more of a gourmand quality. However, the dry down is familiar, and it settles on the skin with musky and woody notes and has a very cozy feel, almost identical to In The Stars. Cloud lasts much longer than In The Stars and projects well. So if you are okay with spending a bit more, you may want to see if Cloud is right for you.

7. Red Temptation by Zara

Red Temptation by Zara
Red Temptation by Zara

Zara is known for releasing impressively accurate dupes of designer fragrances. While In The Stars is not a designer fragrance, Red Temptation is close due to its accord and overall vibe. Red Temptation starts with a familiar citrus note, but there is a bit of spiciness due to a combination of coriander and saffron. The heart was sweeter, and a slight gourmand quality evolved as the fragrance matured. I enjoyed the amber floral base, which reminded me of incense. Overall, the vibe is a little sweeter than In The Stars, but the base is comparable. It lasted for a very long time as well, which was another big surprise for me.

8. Baccarat Rouge 540 by Maison Francis Kurkdjian

Baccarat Rouge by Maison Francis Kurkdjian
Baccarat Rouge by Maison Francis Kurkdjian

If you are okay with shelling out big bucks for a woody amber fragrance like In The Stars, check out Baccarat Rouge 540. While I found the opening almost cloying, the sweetness settles a bit while a heavy dose of amber fills the air. As it matures, the base transforms into a combination of fir and cedar. Overall, the base is similar to In The Stars, though I found Baccarat Rouge 540 much stronger in projection and longevity. However, if you’re interested in this fragrance, be prepared to shell out quite a bit.

9. Burberry Her by Burberry

Burberry Her by Burberry
Burberry Her by Burberry

Burberry Her elicits a sweet and youthful vibe just like In The Stars. However, the accord is more complex, with many more notes. While the opening begins with sweet strawberry instead of citrus, it dries down to a blend of musk, sugar, and wood. I noticed Burberry Her remains a bit sweeter throughout dry down, but earthier notes do appear as the day wears on. Burberry Her has a sparkling creamy vibe similar to In The Stars. I think the main difference is that Burberry Her leads with jammy strawberries while In The Stars opens with juicy citrus notes.

10. Born Dreamer by Charli D’Amelio

Born Dreamer by Charli DAmelio
Born Dreamer by Charli DAmelio

Born Dreamer is a newer fragrance that made its debut in 2022. As it dries down, it becomes reminiscent of In The Stars. In the first few seconds after spraying, I detect a familiar citrus note, but it’s mixed with other notes alongside pear notes. It takes a sugary turn in the middle, though I can also smell fragrant jasmine notes. While amber notes appear at the base, they settle more in the background. It does become a bit muskier than In The Stars, though woody notes create a close vibe.

11. Ambery Saffron by Dossier

Ambery Saffron by Dossier
Ambery Saffron by Dossier

Although Ambery Saffron is another dupe for Baccarat Rouge 540, it shares many of the same qualities as In The Stars. I sensed a bright citrus opening alongside spicy saffron. Additionally, there is a fragrant plum note. Similar to In The Stars, the cedarwood notes elevate throughout wear. Amber notes grow stronger as the fragrance develops, and a warm woody vibe also intensifies. Sadly, Ambery Saffron doesn’t last that long, and you’ll need to reapply or layer it with something more robust to help with projection.

Share now or save for later!

Fragrance Review is dedicated to providing expert opinions, information on trends and the latest product releases from major brands in the fragrance industry. We are passionate about making sure you make an informed decision when it comes to choosing your new fragrance. Read more about us here.

Discover more perfumes

Or

Leave a Comment